
Big Tech, Fascism, and the Stubbornness of a Small Voice
I have a relatively complicated emotional relationship with big tech companies. On the one hand, I’m grateful because never, at any point in history, has it been so easy for some ordinary person, anywhere in the world, to write and publish without having to ask permission from an editor, a printing house, a broadcaster, or someone who held a monopoly over paper, ink, or radio frequencies. On the other hand, with each passing day, it becomes increasingly clear that the very same infrastructure that made my existence in this little corner of the Internet possible also feeds, with obscene efficiency, the machinery of lies, resentment, and violence that the far right has learned to operate better than anyone else.
It’s not hard to understand why. To Big Tech, content is just another raw material, and the ultimate goal isn’t to inform anyone, much less enlighten them or make public life more reasonable. The goal is to keep people inside, scrolling, clicking, reacting, coming back, feeling that something is always happening and that they might miss something if they decide to go live their actual lives outside the app. If that means prioritizing whatever is most obscene, conspiratorial, hateful, or dishonest, then so be it, without the slightest embarrassment.
The algorithm, after all, was designed to maximize engagement, not truth, balance, or the public good. And few things keep people engaged quite like anger, fear, wounded vanity, or the feeling that there’s a war going on and that we might be getting uninvited from civilization without anyone bothering to tell us.
That’s why progressive, humanist, or simply minimally decent voices often feel like they’re rowing against a current that never seems to weaken. It’s not that progressivism has disappeared, or that opposing voices have been driven off these platforms. The problem is that the kind of discourse produced by the far right is extraordinarily well suited to the environment social media has created. Modern fascism has learned to exploit Instagram, YouTube, TikTok, and WhatsApp with a level of competence its representatives rarely demonstrate when they have to discuss history, geopolitics, or economics. It understands that cheap emotional appeals travel faster than reasoned arguments, that publicly humiliating someone is worth more than ten well-written articles, and that sensationalism isn’t an unfortunate side effect, but a way of governing.
As for me, I have absolutely no ambition to be the kind of activist who kicks down doors and wakes up the masses. I admire people who can get out of bed every morning ready for a revolution, complete with flags, a soundtrack, and a respectable amount of theatrical smoke at the entrance. I even think we need those people, because somebody has to make some noise while the rest of us try to remember where we left our glasses. I’d rather keep speaking a little too quietly, a little awkwardly, stumbling over my own words. But even those of us who have no calling for activism end up affected when the very environment of public conversation is controlled by companies that have no genuine interest in knowing what’s true, what’s fair, or what destroys people’s lives, as long as it keeps generating attention.
Of course, it would be convenient to simply declare that Big Tech is just another arm of global fascism and leave it at that. But that would be a cheap oversimplification, the kind we love because it saves us the trouble of making more difficult judgments. The truth is more annoying, and considerably sadder: these companies don’t have to love fascism to serve it. All it takes is for fascism to be profitable, for resentment to attract an audience, for lies to spread more easily than honest doubt, and for some thoroughly unimpressive man to successfully market himself as the victim of a conspiracy, thereby turning his own mediocrity into a national commodity.
And that brings us back to the less attractive side of the story: the realization that technology has democratized many things, cowardice included. Where once you needed to control a television network, a newspaper empire, or an entire political party to manipulate public debate, today all you need is to understand how an app works and keep feeding people’s worst instincts with the consistency of someone working shifts. Technological progress hasn’t freed us from propaganda, demagoguery, or charlatans. It has merely given all three an unprecedented scale.
Even so, I think there’s still some hope, although it’s the kind of hope that looks suspiciously like stubbornness in pretty packaging. The first thing we should do is stop confusing having a social media account with participating in a public sphere. We keep entering these spaces as though they were neutral, as though we were all using the same tools for more or less similar purposes, when in practice some people are there simply to have a conversation and others are there to destroy any possibility of one.
It also helps to stop feeding the very machine we spend so much time criticizing with our own outrage. Don’t share something just to express indignation. Don’t quote it just to refute it. Don’t draw attention to people whose entire existence depends on receiving that attention. Sometimes the only opposition available is refusing to do the other side’s work for free. It’s not a particularly exciting strategy, I know. Nobody is likely to mistake it for a great act of resistance or courage, especially while the world is falling apart around us. But it might be one way to prevent the algorithm from exploiting us even more than it already does.
And perhaps the most important thing is to keep speaking anyway, even if it’s only in small, slightly out-of-place, unfashionable corners of the Internet, like a blog. The advantage of writing somewhere like this is that you can admit, out loud, that you have no idea how to save the world. There’s no need to pretend to have a strategy for optimism, or invent some triumphant solution just so the text doesn’t end with a whimper. I don’t know whether it’s possible to beat Big Tech at its own game. I suspect it isn’t, at least not in the short term. But I also know that the alternative cannot be to fall silent and surrender the field entirely.
So I keep writing, keep questioning, and keep believing that one small voice is still better than absolute silence. Not because I believe this blog will defeat algorithms, platforms, or billionaires with monarchical ambitions, but because accepting that they alone get to decide what deserves to be seen would mean surrendering something even more important: our ability to reject the version of reality they’re trying to force upon us.
It’s not a particularly inspiring conclusion, I know. But I think we can still work with that.