Thumbnail image

This $15 LAMY Safari Has a Tiny Problem

I’ve been thinking about putting together some kind of storefront for the stuff I actually use in my everyday broke-ass journaling. It could save some time for people who want to go down a similar path, while also making me a few bucks through affiliate programs from the usual marketplaces.

It was entirely in the spirit of this noble endeavor that I found myself browsing AliExpress during my lunch break. That’s a lie. I was just looking at stuff. And that’s how I came across a LAMY Safari for $15.61.

Now, fountain pens can be considerably more expensive in Brazil than elsewhere, so the price alone wasn’t enough to convict anyone of anything. Still, $15.61 for a brand-new LAMY Safari looked suspiciously good.

One thing before we go any further: I’m not linking to the listing, affiliate link, or otherwise, because I don’t want to promote counterfeit products. No moral judgment toward people who buy them — some of my best friends are counterfeit buyers. I just know I’d feel cheated if I bought something believing it was genuine, and I don’t want someone else to feel that way because they trusted something I wrote, even if they didn’t bother reading the whole damn post.

The Warning Signs

The price was obviously the first thing that caught my attention.

Then there was the name. “LAMY Vista” is what LAMY calls the transparent version of the Safari. This listing, however, offers several colors and finishes that don’t match the Vista it supposedly sells. And then there’s “Vista Confidence.” As far as I can tell, no such thing exists anywhere on LAMY’s official website. In fact, this particular AliExpress listing seems to be just about the only place on the entire internet where the words “Vista Confidence” and LAMY appear together.

The seller, by the way, doesn’t exactly inspire confidence about the pen’s provenance either. This isn’t an official LAMY store, or even a retailer with an identifiable business name. It’s one of those generic AliExpress stores called something along the lines of “Shop1… Store.”

That doesn’t prove anything by itself. There are thousands of perfectly legitimate sellers on AliExpress with names like that. It just doesn’t help explain how a well-known German pen ended up there for a fraction of its usual price.

There’s another odd detail: LAMY doesn’t normally describe its nib sizes as 0.5 mm and 0.7 mm. It uses the familiar EF, F, M, B, and so on. This listing gives you a choice between 0.5 mm and 0.7 mm.

Then there’s the converter. A standard LAMY Safari doesn’t come with one. LAMY sells it separately, and — at least here in Brazil — it isn’t particularly cheap. Our mysterious AliExpress LAMY comes with a converter included. According to buyers, even the converter proudly wears the LAMY branding.

That’s awfully generous for a pen already selling for a fraction of the price of the real thing.

Look a little more closely at the listing photos and things get even stranger. Most of the promotional artwork really does appear to be LAMY’s — quite possibly saved straight from the company’s website — but the pictures of the colored, non-transparent pens contain the Chinese characters 狩猎者, which online tools translate as Hunter. I don’t speak Chinese. I do, however, know how to use the internet.

That makes me wonder whether we’re looking at a Chinese pen with a design heavily inspired by the LAMY Safari that may originally be identified as Hunter — whether that’s the model name, product line, or something else entirely. The pictures alone aren’t enough to tell us, and they certainly aren’t enough to conclude that there’s a manufacturer called Hunter.

Then I Read the Reviews

And that’s where things get much more interesting.

One buyer apparently already owned a genuine Safari and decided to compare it with the pens he received from AliExpress. According to him, the weight, feel in the hand, and even the writing experience were remarkably similar. The nibs weren’t; the black finish looked different, as well as the markings; more importantly, the feeds were different.

So he did something useful: he tried swapping parts between his known Safari and the two pens he’d bought from AliExpress, and they didn’t fit. The parts from his original Safari were incompatible with the new pens; the parts from the two AliExpress pens, however, were perfectly interchangeable with each other.

His conclusion was that he couldn’t tell whether this was a scam or simply some mysterious “Asian batch.” I have a theory.

Another buyer was considerably less diplomatic. He said the pen was almost identical to the original, that you’d have to know the real thing very well to spot the differences, and that even the LAMY logo is there. He liked how it wrote, too, and happily recommended it to anyone who doesn’t mind buying a cheap imitation. Well then.

Why I’m Not Buying It

If this pen arrived with Hunter written on the barrel, I’d probably be writing a very different post.

Maybe it would be a fantastic Chinese alternative to the Safari, and even write better than mine. For $15.61, I might have bought one just to find out — but that’s not what’s being sold here.

The listing uses LAMY’s name and photographs; it calls the product a LAMY. And, according to the people who actually received one, the pen itself carries the LAMY logo. This isn’t being sold as an inexpensive alternative to the Safari; it’s being sold as a Safari, and that distinction matters to me.

There are some excellent Chinese fountain pens out there for a tiny fraction of what traditional brands charge. Some of them are very obviously inspired by famous designs, but they don’t pretend to be something they’re not.

I own several Chinese pens. I have absolutely nothing against them. Quite the opposite.

That’s kind of the whole point of broke-ass journaling: finding out that you don’t need to spend a fortune just to put ink on paper. But cheap doesn’t have to pretend to be expensive. So, despite my curiosity — and believe me, I really want to know how the damn thing writes — I’m not buying the $15.61 “LAMY.”

It might be an excellent pen with a fantastic nib, so well made that I couldn’t tell it apart from mine without putting the two side by side. But that still wouldn’t make it a LAMY Safari.

And I think I’ll stick with the broke-ass pens that are honest about being broke-ass pens.

Related Posts